The yr 2022 witnessed a renaissance of curiosity-led innovation in digital markets. Most notably, ChatGPT, a “generative Synthetic Intelligence” chatbot powered by Microsoft-backed analysis laboratory OpenAI, went viral. Many analysts say ChatGPT has the potential to upend the search-engine market, which was beforehand thought to be close to unimaginable given Google’s two decades of dominance.
It could be tempting to view such developments as aberrations.
Nevertheless, as we enter 2023, the sudden rise of generative AI serves as a helpful reminder that technological innovation will at all times disrupt the established order and outpace incumbents.
India’s policymakers ought to take a cue from the unbounded potential of innovation and search to allow it by way of three key tech-policy reforms already slated for 2023. These embody the draft Indian Telecommunication Invoice, the draft Digital Private Information Safety (DPDP) Invoice, and the forthcoming Digital India Invoice.
Additionally learn: Why BIS pointers on faux on-line opinions is troublesome to implement
Future-proof knowledge safety
First, the brand new telecom Invoice is meant to carry telecom regulation into the digital period. Nevertheless, the Invoice’s expansive mandate might create hurdles to innovation. It particularly opens the grim prospect of a licensing regime for over-the-top (OTT) communication apps similar to WhatsApp and Sign. In doing so, the Invoice conflates completely different lessons of providers (these distributing spectrum and people distributing internet-based providers) and doubtlessly brings them underneath the identical licensing scheme.
The distinction between conventional telecom providers and OTT providers is that, not like spectrum – a rivalrous useful resource that may be distributed by solely a restricted variety of gamers – the web shouldn’t be scarce. Due to this fact, there may be little justification to carry functions that run atop it underneath licensing that may throttle innovation by creating obstacles to entry for brand new gamers. The truth is, the Telecom Regulatory Authority of India (TRAI) echoed this view as not too long ago as 2020.
Second, the DPDP Invoice is ostensibly a principles-based compliance framework for knowledge fiduciaries (i.e companies that accumulate and course of knowledge), which additionally seeks to allow cross-border knowledge flows. The web is borderless in its conceptualisation, and entry to world markets is crucial for innovation to flourish. Thus, cross-border knowledge flows play an important position in driving extra innovation.
Nevertheless, the federal government workouts discretion to whitelist trusted jurisdictions, which is able to solely enable such flows from some jurisdictions. This whitelist relies on as but unpublished standards. For comparability, even imperfect knowledge safety frameworks such because the European Union’s Common Information Safety Regulation lay down particular rules that allow cross-border knowledge flows. India should additionally specify some goal rules to whitelist different jurisdictions to allow companies to plan prospectively.
India additionally requires a future-proof knowledge safety structure that considers the evolutionary nature of web apps. As an illustration, the centrality of a “discover and consent”-based framework to course of private knowledge, as outlined within the DPDP, is outmoded. This idea originated within the 1990s with the enactment of “knowledgeable consent” in healthcare.
It’s inadequate for an immersive web powered by cloud computing, AI, and prolonged actuality as a result of it burdens customers with obligations to know how their knowledge is used. Even technologists discover it laborious to think about the end-use of all private knowledge collected in future metaverses. India ought to as an alternative prioritise ideas like privacy-by-design that nudge companies to really empower customers slightly than subject notices for the info they accumulate at each flip.
Additionally learn: India should re-think the zero-charge regime for digital transactions. Do this tiered method
Lastly, India is all set to exchange the Data Know-how (IT) Act, a 22-year-old laws that at the moment anchors the nation’s web regulation, with the Digital India Invoice. All indications are that the brand new regime will prioritise ideas like “accountability” by tighter compliances for middleman providers similar to social media and video-on-demand.
Furthermore, studies counsel that the Digital India Invoice might pave the best way for category-based guidelines for middleman providers. However, if such guidelines are too prescriptive or slim, they could inadvertently create category-wise lock-ins. As an illustration, gaming firms might desire to not introduce product improvements similar to social media inside their video games, for worry of further compliance. The purpose is, massive incumbents throughout completely different middleman service classes could also be properly positioned to reply however new entrants will discover it troublesome to conform as their enterprise fashions evolve constantly and occupy completely different classes.
India ought to as an alternative search to foster innovation on the bedrock of a brand new form of “protected harbour” for intermediaries. Secure harbour in web regulation ensures authorized immunity for companies that act as conduits of data and content material in change for good design practices similar to the elimination of unlawful content material. This regulatory idea originated within the US within the mid-1990s and is credited with giving rise to the fashionable web as we all know it.
This idea requires reimagination within the face of beforehand unimagined scale of on-line intermediation, in addition to novel complexities that observe from the rise of decentralised functions of ‘Internet three.zero’. India ought to foster risk-based and activity-based triggers for intermediaries’ liabilities in change for protected harbour.
A legal-regulatory setting that prioritises and fosters innovation can catalyse a billion customers’ participation in India’s ‘techade’. The three upcoming Payments mentioned right here provide a once-in-a-decade likelihood to allow this. Policymakers would do properly to recognise this chance and embrace the innovation potential of expertise, which continues to shock even tech sceptics.
Lalantika Arvind and Vivan Sharan work at Koan Advisory Group, a expertise coverage consulting agency. Views are private.
This text is a part of ThePrint-Koan Advisory sequence that analyses rising insurance policies, legal guidelines and laws in India’s expertise sector. Learn all of the articles right here.
(Edited by Tarannum Khan)
